Abstract of Decisions

Abstract of decisions issued by the Boards of Appeal of the European Patent Office

D 1/23 was an appeal by the epi President against a decision of the epi Disciplinary Committee summarily dismissing a complaint made in respect of two professional representatives. The complaint, submitted anonymously to the epi Secretariat by email, pointed out that the two professional representat …
In G 1/23 the Enlarged Board answered the referred questions as follows: "1. A product put on the market before the date of filing of a European patent application cannot be excluded from the state of the art within the meaning of Article 54(2) EPC for the sole reason that its composition or interna …
In G 1/24 the Enlarged Board ("EBA") considered the points of law referred to it by Technical Board of Appeal 3.2.01 in T 439/22 of 24 June 2024. The first question was whether Art. 69(1), second sentence, EPC and Art. 1 of the Protocol on the Interpretation of Article 69 EPC are to be applied to th …
In G 2/21 the points of law referred to the Enlarged Board addressed two issues: whether the principle of free evaluation of evidence required a qualification in respect of certain evidence relied upon for a purported technical effect in the assessment of inventive step, and the relevant criteria to …
In G 2/24 the Enlarged Board ("EBA") answered the referred questions as follows: "After withdrawal of all appeals, appeal proceedings may not be continued with a third party who intervened during the appeal proceedings in accordance with Article 105 EPC. The intervening third party does not acquire …
In J 1/23 a third party had provided evidence to the EPO that it had instituted proceedings in Sweden against the registered applicant (appellant) seeking a decision within the meaning of Art. 61(1) EPC. The Legal Division had stayed the grant proceedings under R. 14(1) EPC. After the Swedish (appea …
In J 1/24 the Legal Board examined an appeal against the decision of the Receiving Section dated 14 September 2023 that the appellant's European patent application, filed on 24 May 2021, would not be treated as a divisional application. A decision to grant had been issued for the earlier application …
In J 2/22 the Legal Board dealt with the legal (in-)capacity of the appellant, since the notification of the Receiving's Section communication of 21 November 2019 was null and void if the appellant - who was not properly represented - was legally incapable. The Legal Board recalled that legal incap …
In J 3/21 the appeal was filed against the decision of the Receiving Section to reject the applicants' (appellants') request for correction of the originally filed application documents. The Legal Board recalled that, according to established jurisprudence, the general principle was that each party …
In J 3/24 the examination and designation fees (due on Friday, 10 February 2023) had been paid too late (on Monday, 13 February 2023). By letter of 12 February 2023, the appellant's representative had requested that the payment be considered as made on time, as he had wrongly assumed that he had giv …
In J 4/23 the appeal was against the decision of the Legal Division rejecting the appellant's request to be entered on the list of professional representatives before the EPO (the "List"). The appellant had relied on erroneous information published on the EPO's website and based his appeal on the pr …
In J 5/23 the applicant had filed an appeal against the Legal Division's decision rejecting the request to record the transfer of the application. The appeal hinged on how the term "signature" in Art. 72 EPC was to be understood and, in particular, whether it encompassed electronic signatures in the …
In J 6/22 the Legal Board handed down its decision that the request for re- establishment and the appeal be rejected as inadmissible without the oral proceedings requested by the appellant. In its decision, the Legal Board recalled R. 136(1) EPC corresponding to the principle of "Eventualmaxime", un …
In J 9/21 the Legal Division had declared with its communication dated 26 July 2019 that the opposition proceedings had been interrupted as from 11 November 2016 (i.e. as from the day after the expiry of the opposition period) and that they would be resumed on 4 November 2019. After issuing a commu …
See also abstract under Article 113(1) EPC. In J 11/20 the applicant appealed a decision of the Receiving Section refusing their application under Art. 90(5) EPC in conjunction with R. 58 EPC. The sole reason for the refusal was that the four amended drawings filed by the applicant to remedy form …
Interlocutory decision R 4/24 of 19 August 2024 concerned a petition for review against decision T 116/18 of Board 3.3.02 of 28 July 2023. In T 116/18 of 11 October 2021, a referral had been made under Art. 112 EPC to the Enlarged Board, resulting in decision G 2/21, which was then applied in T 116/ …
In R 6/20 the petition for review was based on Art. 112a(2)(c) EPC, i.e. on the grounds that a fundamental violation of the right to be heard (Art. 113(1) EPC) had occurred, whereas the petitioner relied on two asserted procedural defects. The Enlarged Board (EBA) thus assessed whether the decision …
In R 6/22 the petition for review was essentially based on the two grounds that (1) the non-admittance of the auxiliary request had constituted a violation of the right to be heard since the auxiliary request had been submitted in response to a new argument raised by the board, and (2) the board's f …
In R 8/19 the petitioner (opponent 1) claimed that its right to be heard had been fundamentally violated. It had allegedly only learnt from the written reasons of the decision that, when acknowledging inventive step with respect to auxiliary request 1, the board had redefined the objective technical …
In R 11/23 the petition was based on Art. 112a(2)(c) EPC, i.e. the fundamental violation of Art. 113(1) EPC. It was alleged that the clarity objection against auxiliary request 8, which had led to the board's finding that said request had been unallowable, had never been discussed, neither in the wr …
In R 12/23 the Enlarged Board of Appeal (hereinafter referred to as "EBA") summarised the petitioner's assertions concerning procedural deficiencies regarding the ground for petition mentioned in Art. 112a(2)(c) in conjunction with Art. 113(1) EPC as follows: (i) the petitioner had had no opportunit …
In the decision under review in R 25/22 the board had confirmed the revocation of the patent because it had found that the skilled person had had insufficient information to establish the meaning of the "shrinkage ratio" feature. The petition for review was based on the issue that the Reasons given …
In T 19/20 claim 1 of the main request (patent as maintained by the opposition division) corresponded to claim 1 as granted, in which a part had been deleted. The board had to decide on admittance of the appellant's (opponent's) objection under Art. 123(3) EPC against this claim. According to the re …
In T 21/22 document D20 was filed by the appellant (opponent) on the day of the oral proceedings before the opposition division but was not admitted into the proceedings because of its late filing and the fact that it was not prima facie relevant for novelty and inventive step. Although the respond …
In T 25/20 the invention concerned methods and compositions for treating symptoms associated with Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD) using Cyclobenzaprine. Claims 1 and 6 related to second medical uses of a composition comprising cyclobenzaprine. They differed essentially in terms of the thera …
In T 42/19 the board summarised in its catchword the extent to which the board's power extended to reviewing the first instance decision in respect of the evaluation of evidence: "1. A board's power to review appealed decisions is not limited to points of law but extends to points of facts (in agree …
In T 42/22 claim 1 of the main request was a product claim directed to a modified nucleotide, i.e. to a chemical compound as such, which comprised the following components: (i) a purine or pyrimidine base, (ii) a deoxyribose sugar moiety having a 3'- azidomethyl group and (iii) triphosphate. The ap …
In T 43/18 the board agreed with the rationale and the conclusion of T 1085/13 in relation to the assessment of novelty. T 1085/13 was based on the observation that in G 2/10 the Enlarged Board of Appeal had stated that the overriding principle for any amendment to be allowable under Art. 123(2) EPC …
In T 44/19 the appeal was filed by the applicant against the interlocutory decision of the examining division to refuse the request for refund of the second search fee. The application had been filed as an international application. The search examiner, acting as International Search Authority, had …
In T 56/21 the board addressed the question whether Art. 84 EPC provides a legal basis for (i) objecting to an inconsistency between what is disclosed as the invention in the description (and/or drawings, if any) and the subject-matter of the claims, the inconsistency being that the description (or …
See also abstract under Art. 13(2) RPBA 2020. In T 84/19 the board held that the entitlement to pay a reduced appeal fee under the conditions set by Art. 2, item 11, RFees and R. 6(4), (5) EPC must be assessed vis-à- vis the entity which has assumed the procedural status of an appellant. In the ca …
In T 88/21 the board held that the basis for the assessment of the allowability of an undisclosed disclaimer was the claim before the insertion of the disclaimer. The current application and D1 were both filed by the appellant. The current application claimed priority from D0. D1 claimed priority f …
In T 98/23 the patent related to a CRISPR-Cas 9 composition for therapeutic use. It was based on a European patent application resulting from an international PCT application claiming priority from 13 earlier US applications including P1, P2, P3, P5 and P13. In its decision revoking the patent, the …
In T 110/20 the board recalled that in G 1/93 the Enlarged Board acknowledged the inescapable trap that may result from Art. 123(2) and (3) EPC (see point 1 of the Order). The Enlarged Board then went on to specify certain circumstances under which an undisclosed feature was not to be considered to …
In T 111/22 the board interpreted the feature "wherein component (ii) comprises 10-45 wt.% of palatinose" in claim 1 of the patent as granted (main request) in order to compare the claimed subject-matter with the original disclosure. The appellant (patent proprietor) had argued that claim 1 was unc …
See also abstracts under Article112(1)(a) EPC and Article 13(2) RPBA 2020. In T 116/18 (of 28 July 2023) the board observed that in contrast to the questions referred to the Enlarged Board (EBA) in its interlocutory decision of 11 October 2021, which focussed on whether certain evidence proving a c …
In T 124/22 the parties had been summoned to oral proceedings before the board and a communication had been issued under Art. 15(1) RPBA. By letter of reply, received one day before the scheduled oral proceedings, the respondent had stated that it would not be attending the arranged oral proceedings …
In T 130/19 the appellant (patent proprietor) filed a notice of appeal within the two- month time limit. However, due to the erroneous indication "not specified" in the "Method of payment" box on Form 1038E, the debit order for the payment of the appeal fee was not carried out before expiry of that …
In case T 136/24, the therapeutic effect of claim 1 was the treatment of prostate cancer in the specified patient group. Claim 1 was intended to define a new treatment option for mCRPC patients in the form of a cabazitaxel-based combination treatment. The phase III clinical study (TROPIC) presented …
In T 147/22 the respondent (opponent) raised several clarity objections, which were mainly directed to the expression "consisting essentially of" and to the fact that the ingredients cited in claim 1 were associated with a function. On the first aspect, the board noted that the expression "consis …
In T 158/21 the appellant requested in essence that the set of claims annexed as a pdf- file to the electronically filed application be replaced by the set of claims contained in the zip-file which was also attached to the application. The appellant submitted that the version of the claims contained …
In T 169/20 the board disagreed with the findings in T 16/87 and more recent decision T 1473/19 and considered that the provisions of Art. 69(1) EPC did not apply to the interpretation of the claims for the purpose of assessing patentability. The board held that the provisions in Art. 84 EPC and R. …
In T 172/22 the opponent (appellant) had lodged an appeal against the decision of the opposition division concerning maintenance of the patent in amended form on the basis of the then auxiliary request 42 (main request in appeal). The respondent (proprietor) submitted auxiliary requests 42a and 72a …
In T 177/22 the board stated that in order to assess whether the claimed invention is sufficiently disclosed or is novel or inventive, the claimed invention must - to the extent to which this is decisive for the outcome of the case - first be determined by interpreting the claim from the perspective …
In T 178/23 the appellant requested re-establishment of rights under Art. 122 EPC in relation to the non-observance of the time limits under Art. 108 EPC for filing the notice of appeal and paying the appeal fee, and for filing the statement of grounds of appeal. As regards the admissibility of the …
In T 182/20 the invention concerned predicting future malfunctions of mechanical or electrical components based on the current values of one or more parameters. Beyond the server-based processing, the method in claim 1 comprised a number of technical features. Firstly, the method involved measuri …
In T 183/21 the application related to controlling a recommender configured to provide up-to-date predictions of user preferences for products within a large set, for example within a Video on Demand (VOD) catalogue. The claim defined a method of automatically controlling the performance of a recomm …
T 195/23 was an appeal against the interlocutory decision of the opposition division concerning the maintenance of the patent in amended form. The opponents disputed the decision's finding that the priority claim was valid. In particular, they challenged the validity of the priority claim for the al …
In T 196/22 the respondent (patent proprietor) requested to be given time to formulate two questions that should be referred to the Enlarged Board, the first relating to the interpretation of synergy and the second to the standard for not admitting auxiliary requests into the proceedings (here: 11a, …
In T 201/21, the prior art disclosed a system for verifying authentication and ownership of a physical article. Each article included a label having a unique authentication code, pre-stored on a server database. The authentication code can be used to verify authenticity of an item by sending a query …
In T 211/21 the board held that the decision to carry out and monitor manufacturing processes automatically rather than involving the assistance of a skilled artisan, is taken balancing different factors. It has advantages and drawbacks. Automatic systems typically afford higher production rates, in …
In T 215/20 the board held that the objective technical problem could be considered to be that of providing a pharmaceutical composition comprising a crystalline form of dapagliflozin which is more stable, i.e. less hygroscopic. As regards obviousness, the appellant (opponent) argued the skilled pe …
In T 218/20 the respondent (proprietor) initially requested as main request that the appeal be dismissed and alternatively that the patent be maintained on the basis of one of the auxiliary requests 1 to 5, first filed together with the reply to the grounds of appeal. The board accepted that the lat …
In T 221/20 the board had to decide on the admittance of auxiliary requests 1 and 2 and documents K7 and K8. Auxiliary requests 1 and 2 were filed within the time limit set by the opposition division in its summons to attend oral proceedings. Documents K7 and K8 were filed some two weeks later by th …
In T 223/23 claim 1 of the main request was directed at a product as such, namely a trace element solution. It clearly defined the solution by its technical features, i.e. the types and amounts of the trace elements (zinc, manganese, selenium and copper) dissolved therein. The examining division …
In T 228/23 the appellants-opponents had essentially argued that the alleged improvement of drug release when preparing tablets by dry granulation compared to direct compression would not be encompassed by the technical teaching of the original application nor embodied by the same originally disclos …
In T 231/23 the appeal was against the examining division decision rejecting the appellant's request for re-establishment of rights with regard to the time limit for paying the renewal fee for the 6th year with surcharge. According to the board, the admissibility of the appellant's request for re-es …
In T 245/19 both appellants had requested oral proceedings in the event the board had not granted their main request. In the board's preliminary opinion communicated to the parties pursuant to Art. 15(1) RPBA 2020, the board expressed its intention to allow the appellants' main request. Later on, bo …
In T 246/22 auxiliary requests 3 to 8 had already been filed during the opposition proceedings. However, the opposition division did not decide on them because a higher-ranking claim request had already been found allowable. The board noted that the decision under appeal was not based on these reque …
In T 248/22 the board found that the main request and auxiliary request 1 could not be allowed - after the proprietor had withdrawn its appeal - as they were broader than auxiliary request 2 (reformatio in peius), and that auxiliary requests 2 to 5 were not allowable in their substance. Since auxili …
In T 255/22 the board held that it had no competence to correct or amend under R. 140 EPC the reasons given by a first-instance department in the written decision, or to order such a correction or amendment. The reasons for this were essentially twofold and rely on the Enlarged Board's findings in G …
In T 258/21 the appeal was filed by the applicant against the decision of the examining division to refuse the patent application. Claim 1 of main request read as follows: "1. A medicament comprising an effective amount of a short acting dihydropyridine compound wherein the short acting dihydropyri …
In T 279/21 the invention related to a central control system for providing automated real-time interaction and state-transition-controlled processing of (data) objects. The invention was said, rather generally, to provide a system which was capable of flexibly capturing the external and/or internal …
In T 294/20, claim 1 was drafted in the form of a purpose-limited product claim pursuant to Art. 54(5) EPC and was directed to a compound for use in the treatment of nodular lymphocyte predominant Hodgkin lymphoma (NLPHL). The board stated that the Enlarged Board's statements in G 2/21 could be seen …
In T 295/22 claim 1 of "Main request A" was formulated in the "compound for use" format of Art. 54(4) and (5) EPC, wherein the utility as a medicament was further specified as the use as a medicament which is administered orally. The Guidelines G- VI, 6.1.2 - March 2024 version (see example 2: "Comp …
In T 297/20 the board held that the mere change, by an operator, of the degree of abstraction of a graphical view ("condensation") of a power grid did not credibly assist a user in performing a technical task by means of a continued and/or guided human- machine interaction process within the meaning …
In T 302/19 the examining division considered claim 1 as being a straightforward automation of a known manual practice of a laboratory assistant. The board held that for such an argument to succeed, it should be clear what the alleged manual practice is, it should be convincing that it was indeed …
In T 314/20 the board identified three challenges in interpreting point 2 of the Order of G 2/21: the undefined relationship between the new requirements "encompassed by the technical teaching" and "embodied by the same originally disclosed invention", and previous plausibility case law; that the En …
In T 318/22 the patent comprised data demonstrating that compounds falling within the scope of claim 1 possessed herbicidal activity. That the herbicidal activity was improved compared to structurally close compounds of D7 was demonstrated in the post-filed tests of D9 and D10. The appellant (opp …
In T 324/21 the board found that the subject-matter of claim 1 of the main request extended beyond the content of the application as filed due to an unallowable intermediate generalisation, contrary to the requirements of Art. 123(2) EPC. Amended claim 1 of the main request comprised some of the fe …
In T 325/23 the board agreed with the appellant (patent proprietor) that in general there exists no file wrapper estoppel in proceedings under the EPC. A file wrapper estoppel is a concept in US patent law. It refers to the doctrine that the patent proprietor may be estopped from enforcing an interp …
See also abstract under Article 88(3) EPC. In T 335/20 the board found that D9 provided an enabling disclosure of the suitability of PGRN replacement for the treatment of FTD (see also T 609/02). Since document D9 dealt with the same disease as claim 1, identified low levels of PGRN as the cause of …
In T 345/24 the board considered the omission of the qualifier "good" in feature 1.3 of the patent as granted to lack a direct and unambiguous basis in the application as filed. The board explained that, relative to claim 1 as filed, feature 1.3 had been introduced into the claim, in which the acqu …
In T 356/22 the invention sought to provide dosage forms of pomalidomide having advantageous physical and pharmaceutical properties, amongst these being stability. Starting from the pomalidomide composition of claim 22 of closest prior art D1, the differentiating feature was the presence of both ma …
In T 364/20 auxiliary requests 1 to 16 were filed before the opposition division on the final date for making written submissions (R. 116 EPC); auxiliary requests 5, 6 and 16 were identical to auxiliary requests 1 to 3 filed with the reply to the opposition within the time limit set under R. 79(1) E …
In T 366/20 the board was of the opinion, that no technical effect of the distinguishing features could be derived over the whole scope of the claim. The application related to devices and methods for managing the identity of media content data. It is common for the same media content to be availab …
In T 367/20 the board held that to assess whether an amended patent claim contains added subject-matter under Art. 123(2) EPC, the claimed subject-matter must first be determined by interpreting the claim (i.e. establishing the meaning of the claimed features) from the perspective of the person skil …
In case T 387/25 the patent proprietors had appealed the examining division's decision to grant a patent because the drawings had been omitted in the supporting documents indicated in the communication pursuant to R. 71(3) EPC. The board noted that in the present case the drawings clearly formed pa …
In T 396/23 the patent proprietor requested at the oral proceedings that the decision under appeal be set aside and that the patent be maintained on the basis of the main request or on the basis of one of the auxiliary requests 1 to 16 as filed with its statement of grounds of appeal, or auxiliary r …
In T 405/24 the board agreed with the opposition division and the respondents that granted claim 1 contained added subject-matter. Feature 1.7 bore no limitation in respect of the type of "filtered packets" being "routed" to the "proxy system". The appellant argued that "routing filtered packets to …
In T 411/19 appellant II (opponent 2) argued that the subject-matter of claim 1 was not entitled to the earliest priority date because the application from which priority was claimed (P1) did not sufficiently disclose the suitability of the claimed compounds for the claimed therapeutic use, i.e. for …
In case T 412/23, the invention related to a method for determining a suitable colour variant for painting a car without the need for expensive equipment and extensive colour fans. The only state of the art discussed by the appellant was the prior art discussed in the impugned patent itself (E0, E00 …
In T 412/24 the appellant (patent proprietor) had contested the admissibility of the (first) opposition relying on the following points concerning the (first) opponent: (i) the opponent's professional representative could not represent the company since he was simultaneously managing the legal entit …
See also abstract under Article 21 RPBA. Before focusing on the parties' procedural requests, the board in T 417/22 dealt with the patent proprietor's objection of suspected partiality of the legal member of the board. The board recalled that according to Art. 24(3), second sentence, EPC, an objec …
In T 417/24 claim 1 was directed to a content editing method performed by a terminal. The terminal displayed an editable user interface which displayed multimedia and doodle content. The editable user interface comprised a "content editing area" which was used to add or edit the content. The termin …
In T 419/16 of 24 June 2024 the application on which the European patent was granted (the "application") was filed as a PCT application on 15 February 2005 (the "PCT application"). It named (i) parties A1, A2 and A3 as inventors and applicants for the United States of America (US) and (ii) corporati …
In T 423/22 the opposition division had heard witness M by videoconference without the consent of the appellant (patent proprietor). The board considered that Art. 117(1)(d) and R. 117 EPC provided a legal basis for hearing a witness by videoconference. The board furthermore emphasised that hearing …
In T 433/21 the board noted that one line of cases has held that for the withdrawal of an appeal, no rescission under R. 139 EPC or under any other legal basis should be possible: T 1244/08 of 7 July 2011 and T 695/18 of 3 March 2023. The board agreed with T 695/18 on needing to set limits to reques …
In T 438/19 the board identified boards' diverging approaches in applying G 1/92 with regard to the following aspects: (i) interpretation of "available to the public" leading to the exclusion from the state of the art within the meaning of Art. 54(2) EPC of a commercial product (including its chemic …
In T 438/22 the board pointed out that there was no provision stipulating that examples within the meaning of R. 42(1)(e) EPC should not be in the form of claim- like clauses (i.e. in the form of one or more independent clauses followed by a number of clauses referring to previous clauses) at the en …
In T 439/22 the interpretation of the term "gathered sheet" in claim 1 was decisive to assess novelty. In particular, the prior-art document D1 disclosed - in addition to all other features of the claim - a tobacco sheet spirally wound. The board stated that a skilled person in the current technical …
In T 447/22 the board construed the "steering device" in claim 1 as an actual physical component of the machining device which was adapted for actively controlling the direction of the machining device. The board recalled that it was a general principle applied throughout the EPC that a term of a …
See also Abstract under Article 13(2) RPBA In T 449/23, regarding claim 1 of auxiliary request 1 (claims 1 and 2 being identical to claims 2 and 3 of the main request, after claim 1 of the main request was deleted following a finding of lack of inventive step over D5), the board came to the conclusi …
In T 450/20 the board followed the approach taken in T 1473/19, according to which the principles of claim interpretation as set out in Art. 69 EPC and Art. 1 of the Protocol on the Interpretation of this provision are to be applied in proceedings before the EPO. In the present case the understandin …
In T 480/21 the opponent had attempted to file a notice of opposition using EPO Online Filing software on the last day of the opposition period. This transmission had failed. The opponent had then, on the same day, filed the notice by fax, including a copy of the online opposition form 2300E. The fa …
In T 489/20 the board summoned for in-person oral proceedings. It then informed the parties that it would consider the arrangement for the oral proceedings to take place by videoconference if all parties agreed to such format, but that it was not in the position to arrange a video link for the atten …
In T 493/23 the invention related to a threaded pipe connection. The patent had been granted on the basis of an application (the "PCT application") filed on 15 September 2017 published under the PCT and claiming priority from application JP 2016-181176 (the "priority application"). The appellant (op …
In T 500/20 the invention concerned a wind turbine aimed at damping or eliminating undesirable edgewise oscillations of the rotor blades that might appear in an idling power producing situation. The control of the wind turbine altered the nacelle yaw angle if it detected the presence of blade edgewi …
In T 518/22 the board established that the "A3" mutant disclosed in D2 anticipated the subject-matter of claim 1 of auxiliary request 1 at least under Art. 54(3) EPC. Claims 1 and 9 of auxiliary request 2 differed from the respective claims in auxiliary request 1 in that an undisclosed disclaimer h …
T 521/18 was an appeal by the patent proprietor against the decision of the opposition division to revoke the patent for lack of novelty of the subject-matter of claims 1 and 5 of auxiliary request 3 (main request on appeal) over the disclosure of document D4. The prior art document D4 was a Euro-PC …
In T 529/19 the board referred to Opinion G 1/04 where the Enlarged Board came, among other things, to the following conclusion: "1. In order that the subject-matter of a claim relating to a diagnostic method practised on the human or animal body falls under the prohibition of Article 52(4) EPC [EPC …
See also abstract under Article 13(2) RPBA 2020. In T 532/20, the board held that claim 1 as granted defined subject-matter that extended beyond the content of the application as originally filed. This concerned in essence the feature that the generator remained connected to and synchronised with t …
In T 547/21 D2 was the closest prior art, the aim of the disclosed process therein being, inter alia, to increase the concentration of solids in skim milk or whey, an aim shared by the application at issue. The board noted that it could only be acknowledged that recirculating the UF permeate as disc …
In T 552/22 the invention lay in the field of fermentative production of human milk oligosaccharides, in particular the production of fucosyllactose. While the SET family of proteins comprised proteins SetA, SetB and SetC, claim 1 was not limited to these three proteins but related generally to any …
In T 553/25 the applicant had, on 31 January 2025, filed a notice of appeal and paid the appeal fee for persons referred to in R. 7a(2)(a) to (d) EPC as provided for in Art. 2(1), item 11 RFees. By communication of the examining division dated 6 February 2025 (the "Communication"), the applicant was …
In T 558/20 the board had to decide on the proper assessment of novelty under Art. 54(5) EPC, in particular when a claim defines a combined surgical and therapeutic method. The invention concerned a bone regenerative material for use in a method of treating a patient suffering from a degenerative bo …
In T 561/19 the board confirmed the opposition division's decision to award a different apportionment of costs pursuant to Art. 104(1) EPC. At the first oral proceedings before the opposition division, the appellant (opponent) had filed experimental evidence (D15), which was allegedly very relevant …
In T 566/20 the parties disagreed on the interpretation of the feature "the position information in association with the serial number information output from the position control device". The appellant (opponent) submitted that the position control device could output the serial number information …
In T 572/19 the proprietor appealed the opposition division's decision, issued in writing on 17 December 2018, to revoke the patent ("the appealed decision"). By communication under R. 100(2) EPC, the parties were informed of the board's observation that EPO Form 2339, dated 10 December 2018, bore t …
In T 574/17 the board had to decide, among other things, on the admittance under Art. 12(4) RPBA 2007 of evidence (for a public prior use) submitted for the first time on appeal and on the admittance under Art. 13(2) RPBA 2020 of objections based on Art. 123(2) and 54 EPC against auxiliary request 1 …
In T 583/23 the parties agreed that claim 1 related to a closed composition, i.e. a smoke condensate that did not include other components than those stated in the claim. The board noted that claim construction, namely the meaning that a skilled person would give to the wording of a claim, was a qu …
In T 599/21 auxiliary requests 2.1 and 2.2 were filed in response to the board's preliminary opinion. The appellant argued that auxiliary request 2.1 should be admitted into the proceedings since the preliminary opinion of the board contained new arguments. In particular, the reference to page 14 of …
In T 605/20 D3 represented the closest prior art. The difference between the composition of claim 1 as granted and the most pertinent exemplified compositions in document D3 relied upon by the appellant-opponents as starting points in the prior art was not in dispute and concerned the presence of pr …
In T 617/20 the board summoned the parties to oral proceedings in person for 10 October 2024. With a letter dated 1 October 2024 the patent proprietor (sole appellant) withdrew its appeal, which was communicated to the respondent opponents on 2 October 2024. The board cancelled the oral proceedings …
In T 629/22, concerning the inventive step of the subject-matter claimed in auxiliary request 1a-p-s, the board identified D12 as the closest prior art. The claimed subject- matter of a cheese analogue differed from the teaching of D12 at least on account of the type and amount of starch: 10 to 24 w …
In T646/22, the invention concerned input/output circuits and devices having physically corresponding status indicators. It followed from the conclusions on novelty that claim 1 as granted differed from D7 in that the two status indicators were capable of displaying different statuses and that the s …
In T 670/20 the parties agreed that the clinical trials of documents D19 and D20 had been carried out in accordance with the EMEA Guidelines for Good Clinical Practice. These guidelines explicitly required adherence to the prescribed protocol and assurance of drug accountability. This set-up of the …
In T 672/21 the appellant (opponent 2) had provided submissions on obviousness based on the assumption that any improved property was absent, so that the objective technical problem was the mere provision of a further polymorph. It relied in this respect on decision T 777/08. The board, however, …
In T 681/21 the board noted that the formulation of the technical effect differed from that identified in the patent, and thus it was important to verify whether such a formulation was in accordance with the conclusion of the Enlarged Board of Appeal in G 2/21 (point 94 of the Reasons) that "A paten …
In T 686/22 the application related to an information processing apparatus comprising game processing means. An object of the invention was to enable the apparatus to perform game play by splitting a screen at a place, that is on a display means, desired by a user. The apparatus was provided with a …
In T 695/18 the appellant (applicant) had filed a letter on 28 September 2021 which read, among other things: "[w]e herewith respectfully inform the Boards of Appeal that the Applicant herewith withdraws the appeal. A partial refund of the appeal fee is requested". The board considered that the app …
In T 697/22 the board agreed with the appellant-opponent that there was an inconsistency between claim 1 of auxiliary request 1E, which required that a specific feature was mandatory, and the amended description as filed during the oral proceedings before the opposition division, according to which …
In T 702/20 the board held that a neural network defines a class of mathematical functions which, as such, was excluded matter. As for other "non-technical" matter, it could therefore only be considered for the assessment of inventive step when used to solve a technical problem, e.g. when trained wi …
In T 703/18 the patent related to an infant formula containing combinations of lutein and docosahexaenoic acid. For the respondent the correct technical problem was the one identified in the decision under appeal. In its view, the patent involved one of the rare cases of a "problem invention". It ha …
In T 712/21 the applicant filed an appeal against the decision of the examining division to refuse the patent application for non-compliance among others with the requirements of Art. 84 EPC. The examining division had argued that the invention was defined in terms of a result to be achieved, namely …
In T 714/20 the appellant (applicant) had requested that a patent be granted on the basis of a main request or one of two auxiliary requests, all filed with the grounds of appeal. These requests corresponded respectively to the main request filed in advance of the oral proceedings before the examini …
In T 733/23 the opposition division had concluded that there had been insufficient evidence to prove that the data sheets D2, D4, and D7 to D9 had been made available to the public before the filing date. Rather than concluding that, as a result of the data sheets not being considered state of the a …
During the oral proceedings in T 737/20 the board informed the parties that it had decided not to remit the case to the opposition division and intended to deal with the issue of inventive step itself. Subsequently, the appellant raised an objection under R. 106 EPC to the effect that its right to b …
In the course of the written proceedings before the board in T 744/23, the respondent (opponent) had requested, inter alia, that the oral proceedings be conducted in person. In its communication pursuant to Art. 15(1) RPBA the board had taken note thereof and had added that it would, however, be ap …
In T 745/23 the board had summoned the parties to oral proceedings on the EPO premises. The respondent had requested that the oral proceedings be held by videoconference. The appellant had requested, in response, that the oral proceedings be held in person, or, alternatively, that the board refer to …
In T 746/22 both the opponent and the patentee had appealed against the interlocutory decision of the opposition division maintaining the European patent in amended form. Regarding independent claim 15 of the main request, both parties agreed with the board's finding that feature F2 was the only di …
In ex parte case T 748/19 the application related to identifying events in scenes under surveillance. The board remarked in its preliminary opinion that claim 1 defined a method for identifying events without any definition of the events which were classified. Hence it covered in principle any event …
In T 758/20 the board decided of its own motion to hold oral proceedings by videoconference pursuant to Art. 15a(1) RPBA 2020. The oral proceedings were held by videoconference in November 2022 with the consent of the respondent (patent proprietor). The appellant (opponent) had not consented to that …
In T 761/20 the invention related to automated assessment of scripts written in examination, in particular English for Speakers of Other Languages (ESOL) examinations. The board held that though G 1/19 was related to computer-implemented simulations, its reasons apply to computer-implemented method …
In T 778/21 (laundry appliance), the opposition division concluded inter alia that the subject-matter of claim 1 of the patent as granted was not new in view of both document E2 and the prior use (PU) relating to a washing machine. Both parties appealed. The opponent alleged that the sale of the pri …
In T 795/21 the parent application as originally filed defined variables X and Y for the compounds of formula I as follows: "X and Y are independently selected from the group comprising H, F, Cl, Br, I, OH and methyl (-CH3)". It was not in dispute that amended claim 1 of auxiliary request 4 included …
In T 799/24 the invention concerned a method and device for analysing optimisation of vehicle body joint position. The aim of the invention was to provide an analysis apparatus for determining an optimal location of an additional welded point to be added to a portion to join a part to an assembly of …
In T 806/21 the board held that, as ruled in decision G 1/10, R. 140 EPC is not available to correct patents. G 1/10 does not restrict the scope of the exclusion of the applicability of the rule in any way. The appeal of the patent proprietors was against the decision of the examining division to r …
In T 814/19 the objective technical problem was found the provision of an olaparib formulation suitable as a pharmaceutical dosage form for administration to patients. The appellant (opponent) contested that this problem was solved across the whole breadth of claim 1 because the claim was drafted t …
In T 814/20 the board was satisfied that the claimed method for the re-identification of objects captured by image cameras was a technical purpose because it was tantamount to an objective measurement in physical reality: is the object observed now the same as the one observed earlier? It remained t …
In case T 816/22, the patent contained data from a randomised, double-blind, placebo- controlled pilot study to evaluate the safety and efficacy of Cinryze (C1 esterase inhibitor [human]) for the treatment of acute antibody-mediated rejection (AMR) in recipients of donor-sensitised kidney transplant …
In T 823/23 the board decided on the admittance of a "carry-over objection", i.e. - as explained by the board - an objection which was raised and maintained in the opposition proceedings but which was not decided upon in those proceedings, neither with regard to its admittance nor in substance, due …
In T 832/22, several pieces of evidence were submitted by the opponent (appellant) to establish the publication date of document D9, a user manual issued by the opponent. The respondent (proprietor) considered that it was not sufficiently proven that D9 had been published on the internet before the …
See also abstract under Article 104(1) EPC. In T 846/22 the respondent (patent proprietor) questioned the status of the appellant as a legal person in the context of Art. 99(1) EPC, according to which "any person may give notice to the European Patent Office of opposition [ ... ] in accordance with …
In T 852/20 the board addressed the issue of whether post-published experimental data could be used to demonstrate a technical effect that was not explicitly derivable from the application as filed. In the impugned decision, the opposition division had rejected the opposition filed against the pa …
In T 866/24, during the oral proceedings before the board, the opponent (respondent) submitted that the unclear features underlying the amendments made to claim 1, which were based on the patent description, were building up on corresponding unclear formulations taken from dependent claim 6 as grant …
In T 867/23 the board decided on the basis of the patent as granted (main request). Claim 1 was worded as a purpose-limited product claim in accordance with Art. 54(5) EPC. The treatment of "primary negative symptoms of schizophrenia" was a functional feature of claim 1. The parties were in disput …
In T 873/21 the application related to compound (A) (also referred to as velagliflozin) and compound (B) (also referred to as pergolide) for use in the treatment and/or prevention of Equine Metabolic Syndrome (EMS), Equine Pituitary Pars Intermedia Dysfunction (PPID or equine Cushing's syndrome) and …
In T 873/23 claim 1 as granted was amended with respect to claim 1 as originally filed inter alia by Feature 1.5x, specifying that, for an electric coil cooktop and an electric glass ceramic cooktop, the control device was configured to control the power level of the cooktop "by turning the heating …
In T 878/23 claim 1 of the main request concerned a product claim. The claimed composition comprised an amino acid combination selected from seven combinations containing two or three amino acids selected from cysteine, alanine, lysine and arginine. Claim 1 further specified that the composition co …
See also abstract under Article 12(6) RPBA. In T 883/23 the board had to decide whether claim 1 of the main request was entitled to claim priority from the earliest priority application (P1). P1 disclosed a method for treating pancreatic cancer in a human subject who has not previously received che …
In T 887/21 the patent in suit sought to provide a method for the prevention of secondary infections following viral infections such as influenza, which did not rely on the use of antibiotics and which may be conveniently and safely administered. The respondent (patent proprietor) argued that, in vi …
In T 929/18 the examining division had refused the application for lack of inventive step without referring to any prior art documents. In particular, claim 5 referred to mobile user devices in a "peer-to-peer" data sharing group. Each mobile user device of the data sharing group stored the shared …
T 933/18 was an appeal against the opposition division's decision to reject the opposition. The patent had been granted on a divisional application of an earlier European patent application (the parent application) filed as an international patent application. Claim 1 as granted related to a method …
In T 939/22 claim 1 of the main request was directed to "a vaccine comprising a recombinant nonpathogenic Marek's Disease Virus (rMDVnp) comprising a first nucleic acid (...) and wherein the rMDVnp is a recombinant herpesvirus of turkeys (rHVT)." The construction of rMDVnp was relevant for assessing …
In T 953/22 the board noted that the wording of Art. 123(3) EPC was not identical to the wording of Art. 123(3) EPC 1973, which read: "The claims of the European patent may not be amended during opposition proceedings in such a way as to extend the protection conferred." (emphasis added by the board …
In T 957/22 after having withdrawn its own appeal, the proprietor in its respondent's role was therefore limited to defending the patent in the form held allowable by the opposition division, or in a more restricted form. The numbering of auxiliary requests 2-13 (lower ranking compared to the reque …
In T 964/21 the patent proprietor (appellant) requested, among other things, that the opposition division's decision as to the apportionment of costs be set aside. The formulation of that decision was set out in the Reasons of the impugned decision as follows: "... the Opposition Division apportions …
See also abstract under Rule 142 EPC. In T 967/18 both parties had filed a request for a different apportionment of costs under Art. 104 EPC. Two weeks before the oral proceedings the respondent (opponent) had filed a request that the costs it incurred in preparing and filing the reply to the stat …
In T 989/23 auxiliary request 17, filed with the statement of grounds of appeal, had first been filed in the opposition proceedings on the final date set under R. 116 EPC. The opposition division had decided that this auxiliary request was not open for examination as to its admissibility since it ha …
In T 1001/18 the invention related to a coin token assembly for use in a vending machine dispensing coin tokens. The board found D3 to be the most suitable spring- board for the problem and solution approach, whereas the impugned decision relied on D1 as the closest prior art. The board found that D …
In T 1006/21 both parties requested remittal of the case to the opposition division, albeit under different conditions. The respondents (opponents) also requested that the appellant's (patent proprietor's) request for remittal not be considered for being late-filed. The board recalled that the disc …
In T 1045/21 the board held that the technical problem could not be formulated as the provision of an effective and thus improved treatment of ALS with edaravone, wherein the improvement resides in the provision of a further (new) treatment option for ALS, because D1 already described an effective t …
See also abstract under Article 76(1) EPC. In T 1050/22, with regard to obviousness, the relevant question was whether the skilled person would have contemplated a reduction of the amount of mannitol to less than 0.5 w/v%, by partially replacing mannitol with propylene glycol and/or glycerine, wh …
In T 1054/22 the examining division had concluded that claim 1 of the main request did not fulfil requirements of Art. 123(2) or 76(1) EPC, among other things, and it refused the patent application. In its submissions on appeal, the applicant had argued that applying the criteria of G 1/93 (point …
In T 1058/20 claim 1 of the new first auxiliary request, filed after notification of the summons to oral proceedings, was limited to only one of three alternative embodiments (alternative (iii)) claimed in claim 1 of the main request. The board, referring to case law cited in T 2920/18 and in T 494/ …
See also abstract under Article 84 EPC. In case T 1065/23, the purpose of the invention was the provision of a pea protein composition comprising pea proteins having a low solubility. Such protein extracts had superior properties when used in processes for manufacturing bakery products and beverage …
In T 1076/21, with reference to T 585/92, the respondent (opponent) argued that the appellant (patent proprietor) bore the burden to prove that the patent was sufficiently disclosed because the opposition division had revoked the patent. The appellant contested that the respondent had successfully d …
In ex parte case T 1078/23, the decision of the examining division refused the European patent application for, at least, lack of inventive step; the examining division considered prior-art document D1 "to be the prior art closest to the subject-matter of claim 1". The appellant submitted that docum …
In T 1079/18 D2 was found by the board to be the closest prior art and form A was singled out as clearly preferred among the solid forms of febuxostat disclosed therein, in particular because it was the most suitable for the preparation of pharmaceutical formulations. This was the same context as th …
In T 1084/22 the patent concerned insulating glazing units, which typically consist of two glass sheets separated by a perimeter spacer. Specifically, it related to a method for creating such units. This involved providing a spacer body with adhesive on both sides in a storage container. Claim 1 was …
In T 1099/21 claim 1 of the application as originally filed essentially related to a coating composition comprising a microencapsulated biocide and a free (i.e. not microencapsulated) isothiazolone biocide or antifouling agent. The feature relating to the upper concentration limit of the free isoth …
In T 1105/17 the board stated that it had consistently been decided by the boards of appeal (see, e.g. T 1539/09 and T 790/14) that the design or provision of programming language constructs per se did not contribute to the solution of a technical problem and could not therefore contribute to the pr …
In T 1121/21 the opposition division in the appeal at issue had rejected the opposition as inadmissible pursuant to R. 77(1) EPC, having found an apparent lack of a clear indication of the opponent in the notice of opposition and in the accompanying letter. The board noted that the letter of opposi …
In T 1126/19 the patent was directed to new polymorphic forms of rucaparib salts. Rucaparib is used in cancer therapy to potentiate the effect of radiotherapy or cytotoxic drugs which cause DNA damage. The invention was based on the finding that crystalline rucaparib camsylate was particularly su …
In T 1127/23 the respondent (patent proprietor) argued that the appeal of appellant 1 (company Y GmbH) was inadmissible because the transfer of the opposition from company X OG (original opponent 1) to company Y GmbH (its universal successor) was invalid. Appellant 1 admitted that it had been acting …
T 1128/19 was an appeal against the decision of the examining division to refuse the European patent application. The application was a divisional application of an earlier application which was subsequently granted (the parent patent). The examining division had held that the main request and auxil …
In T 1133/21 the respondent (patent proprietor) submitted that although multiple selections had to be made to arrive at the claimed subject-matter, the teaching of the application as filed taught toward the claimed combination of features. In essence, the respondent argued that since i) the ranges i …
In T 1138/20, the main question was whether the opposition division had correctly found that NPL1 was made available to the public. The appellant (patent proprietor) challenged the opposition division's findings of fact that NPL1 was the presentation that had been delivered to the European Space Age …
In T 1152/21 the board concluded that claim 1 of auxiliary requests 9b and 10a did not meet the requirements of Art. 84 EPC. Claim 1 of auxiliary request 9b included the term "cooling to an appropriate temperature". The board found that the skilled person could not assess whether a particular tempe …
In T 1158/17 the invention concerned a system for secure delivery of business mailings, for example contracts or invoices. The board was not convinced by the contested decision's finding that the claimed components were not technical because they modelled the roles of humans interacting within the f …
In T 1158/20 the first point of the board's Catchword reads as follows: "Pursuant to Art. 15a(1) RPBA 2020 the boards have a discretionary power to hold oral proceedings by videoconference without the consent of all parties. When exercising this discretion, the board must primarily assess whether th …
In T 1178/23 auxiliary request 4 filed with the reply to the statement of grounds of appeal had the same wording as auxiliary request 2 in opposition proceedings, filed as auxiliary request 1 on the final date set by the opposition division under R. 116 EPC and renamed when a new auxiliary request 1 …
In T 1208/21 the board rejected the respondent's (patent proprietor's) approach of a limited interpretation of the expression "gas turbine blade" in claim 1 in the light of the description. The board held that according to the commonly accepted approach on claim interpretation by the boards of ap …
In the decision at issue in T 1219/19, the opposition division had decided not to admit auxiliary request 6, which was filed by the appellant during the oral proceedings. According to the opposition division, it had been filed late, was an attempt to address an issue already raised in the notices o …
In T 1220/21 auxiliary requests 2 and 3, filed by the respondent with its reply to the appeal, corresponded to two auxiliary requests, which, in the board's view, had been admissibly raised and maintained in the opposition proceedings. They were thus not regarded as an amendment under Art. 12(4) RPB …
In T 1224/24 the appeal was directed against the decision of the examining division to grant a European patent on the basis of the application documents indicated in the communication under R. 71(3) EPC dated 13 December 2023. This communication had not indicated that the text intended for grant di …
In T 1231/20 the application aimed to provide a microcontroller with a more flexible configurability of a digital clock source that could be used as a system clock or as a clock source for peripheral devices or other uses. In order to achieve this aim, the microcontroller further comprised a multipl …
In T 1245/20 the application related to methods of identifying an application type of unknown data that may be encountered during a data recovery process. The board held that the construction of the mapping according to the claimed invention was performed based on non-technical rather than technical …
In T 1246/21 the appellant (patent proprietor) appealed against the opposition division's decision to revoke the patent. As an auxiliary measure, the proprietor requested that the patent be maintained on the basis of claims according to one of the auxiliary requests filed with the statement of groun …
See also abstract under Article 56 EPC. In T 1249/22 the application related to the development - including the training - of an analytical model (e.g. a machine learning model) and the deployment of the trained analytical model on a "compute engine" so as to process live incoming data. The examini …
In T 1252/20 claim 1 of the applicant's main request related to "a composition for use in reducing or eliminating cancerous cells" by blocking the blood supply to the tumour. The claim defined the composition as a peptide solution forming a hydrogel once inside the body. The peptide was defined by i …
In T 1261/21 the board established that in claim 1 of auxiliary request 26, the deodorisation time and the deodorisation temperature were limited based on a disclosure of converging numerical ranges or converging elements of the same feature (also named "converging alternatives" in some board decisi …
In T 1262/22, the respondents (patent proprietors) alleged that the appeal was inadmissible because the notice of appeal was filed by a professional representative (K) who was not authorised at the time of filing. Under Art. 1(1) of the Decision of the President of the EPO dated 12 July 2007 on the …
In T 1266/19 claim 1 of the main request (patent as granted) was directed to a method which comprised at least six process steps. The process steps (i) to (v) defined a chronological order in which the claimed method had to be performed. It was, however, disputed between the parties whether step (vi …
In T 1272/22 the appellant (opponent) and respondents (patent proprietors) disputed whether there was a synergistic effect between the distinguishing features, even if it were considered they served the same purpose. The board, applying Headnote II of G 2/21, could not see that the skilled person wo …
In T 1285/23 the proceedings initially started with the Receiving Section's refusal to add GB as a designated state. In J 13/18 the Legal Board dismissed an appeal against that decision. It interpreted Art. 76(2) EPC and concluded that adding GB as a designated contracting state would contravene it, …
In T 1286/23 one of the opponents (the "appellant") filed an appeal against the decision of the opposition division. Thereafter, a third party (the "intervener") declared an intervention and filed an appeal against the opposition division's decision, paying the fees for both opposition and appeal. T …
See also abstract under Article 13(1) RPBA 2020. T 1303/18 was an appeal against the opposition division's decision to revoke the patent. The patent had been granted with an earliest priority date of 28 November 2007 claimed from D49. The respondents (opponents) objected to the validity of this ea …
See also abstract under Article 12(6) RPBA. In T 1311/21, concerning the public availability of the user manual E7, written by the company Sensors, Inc., the board addressed in detail the question of standard of proof. The board noted that neither of the two standards of proof "balance of probabil …
In T 1349/19 the objective technical problem was the provision of an alternative vegetable-derived fat composition which could mimic the fat composition of human milk and which could be produced in a simple and cost-effective manner. It was not contested that this problem had been solved b …
See also abstract under Article 056 EPC. In T 1356/21 claim 1 of the main request pertained to an aqueous pharmaceutical formulation characterised in particular in that "the concentration of insulin glargine is 270-330 U/mL being equimolar to 270-330 IU human insulin". This feature of claim 1 def …
In T 1361/19 the board had to decide on the admittance of the new main request filed during the oral proceedings before the board. The new main request was limited to "a method of manufacturing a semiconductor device", the device claims having been deleted. The board noted that the question of whet …
In T 1403/24 the appellant (patent proprietor) contested the admissibility of the opposition filed by opponent 2. It argued that opponent 2 was acting on behalf of opponent 1 or opponent 3. In the appellant's view, this followed from the citation of document D24 in the notice of opposition by oppone …
In T 1408/19 the appeal was against the decision of the opposition division rejecting the opposition. The opposition division had held that the opposition was admissible and, in particular, that the requirements of R. 76(2)(c) EPC had been met. The respondent (patent proprietor) argued that said opp …
In T 1424/23 the board explained that when assessing compliance with Art. 123(2) EPC, it has to be established whether the application has been amended in such a way that it contains subject-matter which extends beyond the content of the application as filed. Citing G 3/89, the board recalled that t …
In T 1426/21 the board followed decision T 1444/20 finding that the "specific embodiments of the invention" drafted as claim-like clauses in the description (of the new main request), which were consistent with the claims did not render the claims unclear pursuant to Art. 84 EPC and met the requirem …
In T 1439/21 the application related to an automated elderly insurance scheme. The board emphasised that for deciding whether a feature is technical or not for assessing inventive step under the EPC, it is not relevant which person makes the contribution in real life. In real life, a person skilled …
In T 1445/21 the claimed invention related to near anhydrous liquid detergent and conditioner products comprising encapsulated perfumes which are perfectly stable therein. The appellant relied on the experimental data in the patent as granted, and on the experimental data in the experimental report …
In T 1445/22 the appellant requested the admittance into the appeal proceedings of late-filed documents D10 to D12, D14, D15 and D20, which had not been admitted into the opposition proceedings for being prima facie not relevant with respect to the sufficiency of disclosure objection, as well as D26 …
In T 1456/22 the appeal was against the decision of the examining division to grant the patent. The applicant had requested the postponement of the examining division's decision to grant, as it wished to wait until the Unitary Patent system was in effect. The applicant had also requested that, only …
In T 1465/22 the appellant (opponent) had contested the opposition division's findings that although the method steps of claim 1 could be carried out manually, this did not render them non-technical, as the performance of a manual activity was not a purely mental act. According to the appellant, the …
In case T 1465/23, the opposed patent addressed the problem of securing wireless communications for hearing devices. The board was not satisfied that the technical effects mentioned by the respondent (proprietor) were credibly achieved by the claimed features over the whole scope of claim 1 as grant …
In T 1468/21 the differentiating features solved the technical problem of providing a fully autonomous locker. Feature [C] related to a particular way of creating or determining the opening code and of storing it in the locker. Features [E], [F], [G] and [H] related to the specific set-up of an auto …
In T 1469/24, the appellant-proprietor contested the admissibility of the opposition, arguing that the opponent had not been correctly identified, so that the requirements of Art. 99(1) and R. 76(2) EPC were not met. They argued that the opponent, Mr N.N., was the representative of one of the subsid …
In T 1473/19 the parties presented two possible interpretations for a feature in claim1 of the granted patent. The interpretation of such feature was relevant for assessing compliance with Art.123(2) and (3) EPC. Although the tests to be carried out under these provisions were differ …
See also abstract under Rule 124(1) EPC. In T 1482/21 the appellant (opponent 2) argued that the decision of the Receiving Section granting a request for re-establishment of rights in relation to the priority period was invalid, due to the Receiving Section's lack of competence to take this decisio …
In T 1484/19 of 04.07.2023 the board decided on requests for reimbursement of the appeal fee and apportionment of costs filed on the day of completion of the internal decision-making process for the previous decision T 1484/19 of 29.11.2022. With its letter dated 24 November 2022, the patent propri …
In T 1515/20 the board noted that in opinion G 3/89 and decision G 11/91, the Enlarged Board had held that corrections under R. 88, second sentence, EPC 1973 (now R. 139, second sentence, EPC) were special cases of an amendment within the meaning of Art. 123 EPC and fell under the prohibition of ext …
In T 1518/20 the board found that starting from D1 as the closest prior art, a skilled person seeking to provide a mere alternative surface-crosslinking process for superabsorbent polymers (SAPs) exhibiting good CRC, AUP, SRC and gel strength would have applied the teaching of D11 to the polymer syn …
In T 1522/21 the opposition division had admitted document D11 into the proceedings finding it prima facie relevant. The opponent had filed document D11 after the nine- month period under Art. 99(1) EPC but before the final date for making written submissions according to R. 116(1) EPC. The patent p …
The decision under appeal in T 1525/19 concerned the opposition division's decision to reject the five oppositions filed against the patent at issue for a solid pharmaceutical dosage form comprising linagliptin as a first active pharmaceutical ingredient in an amount of 5 mg and empagliflozin as a s …
In T 1526/22 the application related to a method (and a corresponding apparatus) for estimating a "state" of an ego vehicle, for use in a motor vehicle driver assistance system for the ego vehicle. The examining division had objected that claims 1 and 12 failed to meet the requirements of Art. 84 EP …
In T 1529/20 the appellant (proprietor) submitted that they had never received the decision of the opposition division revoking their patent and that they had only become aware of it and, more generally, of the opposition proceedings, through an email from a formalities officer of the EPO. The boar …
In T 1535/23 the board observed that the Court of Appeal of the Unified Patent Court ("CoA UPC") in UPC_CoA_382/2024 applied the same test as the EPO to determine whether an amendment extended beyond the content of the application as filed. This test is known as the "gold standard" (see G 2/10). Th …
In T 1544/22 the patent proprietor (respondent) submitted a letter, relating inter alia to auxiliary request 2, only two working days before the oral proceedings. They argued that this letter was a direct response to the board's preliminary opinion, which deviated from the impugned decision. Accordi …
In T 1553/22, the application concerned the generation of pig-human chimeric animals with the aim of using them as a source of human vasculature and blood. The appellant's arguments could be summarised as follows: The examining division's approach to chimeras was unduly restrictive and was not in li …
In T 1571/19 the appellant (opponent) argued that the skilled person, starting from D5 (the closest prior art) and faced with the underlying problem, would have taken into account the teaching of D3, which, like the opposed patent, related to a feed composition (for fish) for treating inflammatory s …
In the proceedings leading to the decision under appeal in T 1588/22, the examining division had issued a communication on 27 July 2021. The last paragraph of the communication had read as follows: "The applicant may choose to amend the claim set as previously proposed by the examining division (see …
In T 1591/23 the board considered the exercise of the examining division's discretion pursuant to R. 137(3) EPC. The examining division had decided not to admit auxiliary requests XV to XXVI before the text thereof was submitted by the applicant. According to the appealed decision auxiliary request …
In T 1602/21 the opposition division had decided that the provision of a method according to claim 1 of the patent as maintained involved an inventive step. One of the differing features to closest prior art D1 was seen in the nature of adsorbent, i.e. an OH- type basic ion-exchange resin (alternati …
In T 1604/22, the opposition division found the two public prior uses regarding dialysis machine and POL software alleged by the opponent (respondent) to be proven. Two witnesses were heard and a CD was inspected during the oral proceedings, which were held by videoconference. The opposition divisio …
In T 1617/20 the appellant (proprietor) filed as main request a set of clams identical to the claims of auxiliary request 2 underlying the appealed decision as well as amended pages of the description. As regards the amended description, the board examined whether it should have been submitted in o …
In T 1618/19 the claimed subject-matter related to a concrete apparatus, namely a blending control system in a refinery, and a corresponding method. The claimed blending control apparatus/method comprised a computer modelling apparatus/method. The modelling was performed for an active refinery proc …
In T 1623/21 the board found the reasons of the appealed decision for showing that the subject-matter of claim 1 lacked an inventive step not convincing. Contrary to the examining division's view expressed in the appealed decision, overlaying information onto a received sensory work at a specific i …
In T 1628/21 claim 1 was directed to an article of apparel comprising among other things "a lower back position feedback system (202) engaged with the garment structure at the lower back portion". The interpretation of the expression "engaged with" was relevant in the context of assessing novelty an …
In ex parte case T 1632/22, the application related to liveness detection in relation to authentication, e.g. when unlocking a phone based on a face image. The application proposed to categorise the images as a function of their "quality" and to use different liveness detectors for each quality type …
In T 1650/23, the invention concerned controlling the display of content items provided by a website or an application. In the system according to the invention, the content of a content item to be displayed is reduced to an amount that enables a user "to understand the target content item within th …
In T 1656/17 the appellant raised an objection of suspected partiality against all members of the board under Art. 24(3), first sentence, EPC. The objection was deemed admissible and an alternate board was formed. A technically qualified member of the alternate board then informed it in a notice of …
In T 1678/21 the appellant (applicant) had filed a notice of appeal within the time limit prescribed in Art. 108 EPC. The notice, filed on 6 September 2021, included instructions on Form 1038E to debit the reduced appeal fee. Moreover, the final sentence of the notice of appeal read as follows: "Any …
In T 1686/21 the main request was filed by the respondent as auxiliary request 1f" during the oral proceedings before the board in reaction to the board's finding that the omission, in claim 1 of the patent as maintained, of a certain feature resulted - contrary to the assessment of the opposition d …
In T 1688/20 the board referred to the three criteria developed in T 198/84, as summarised in T 279/89, according to which a selection of a sub-range of numerical values selected from a broader range was considered novel, when each of the following criteria was satisfied: (a) the selected sub-range …
In T 1708/18 the argument of the patent proprietor (appellant I) in relation to novelty was that the correct standard for the assessment of novelty was "beyond reasonable doubt", i.e. it had to be beyond doubt, and not merely probable, that the claimed subject-matter was directly and unambiguously d …
In T 1726/22 the claimed subject-matter was defined by parameters; however, even though the claims related to an acetylated wood as such, the parameters, i.e. the shrinkage ratios, were defined in relation to the wood before acetylation. The application did not mention anything regarding how the shr …
In T 1731/19 the board decided not to take auxiliary requests 1 to 3 into account because the respondent failed to substantiate these requests in its reply to the appellant's statement of grounds of appeal. These requests were identical to auxiliary requests 1 to 3 submitted during the opposition pr …
In T 1741/22 the board referred to G 1/19 to show that it is generally acknowledged that measurements have technical character, since they are based on an interaction with physical reality, such as the human or animal body (see also G 1/04). However, the board went on to find that in the case at han …
In T 1750/19 the board found that D4 was a suitable starting point for the assessment of inventive step. The appellant, on obviousness, argued that the skilled person knew from D8 that basically any low molecular weight compound having two functional groups that react with isocyanate may be used as …
See also abstract under Art. 123(2) EPC. In T 1762/21 the appellant (opponent) disputed the validity of the priority claim for the subject-matter of claims 1 and 7 of the main request. It argued that the validity of the priority claim could not be assessed by applying the same criteria as for the a …
In T 1768/20 the application related to generating a design model for a chip design by means of a design tool and simulation. The board stated that decision G 1/19 was now the essential case law that had to be considered when assessing inventive step in the current case. According to point 97 of G 1 …
In T 1774/21 the appellant had raised a new objection under Art. 123(2) EPC against a feature of the main request (patent as maintained by the opposition division) in its statement of grounds of appeal. The respondent, after first having replied to this allegedly new line of attack with counter-argu …
In T 1776/18 the board first dealt with the legal basis for not admitting amended claim requests. It cited a long line of case law according to which claim requests may be disregarded under Art. 114(2) EPC, as well as examples of case law in which the opposition division's discretion not to admit cl …
T 1779/19 concerned an appeal against the decision to reject the opposition against the European patent, which disclosed in claim 1 a "Method for preventing chlorine deposition on the superheater of a boiler in which a fuel with a chlorine content is burned, and to which boiler a compound with a sul …
In T 1779/21, the board, stressing that G 2/21 confirmed most of the case law on sufficiency of disclosure, summarised in this respect the contribution of G 2/21 (points 74, 77 of the Reasons) as to whether a therapeutic effect had been shown to be achieved, notably that "it is necessary that the pa …
In T 1806/20 the invention claimed in the main request concerned a parcel delivery system that sought to prevent damage to water-sensitive parcels by avoiding delivery to rainy destinations. A delivery vehicle is equipped with a satellite navigation system, for example within a tablet (not claimed), …
See also abstract under Article 13(2) RPBA 2020. In T 1807/15 the respondent (patent proprietor) had requested that costs be apportioned to the appellant (opponent) because: (a) the appellant had not given advance notice to the respondent of its intention to request a referral to the Enlarged Board …
In T 1809/20 appellants 1 and 2 (opponents) objected that claim 1 of the main request contained subject-matter extending beyond the content of the application as filed. Claim 1 of the main request related to a method for producing a certain purified protein. The board agreed that, as submitted by t …
In T 1816/22 the appellant's objection of lack of novelty of claim 1 as granted was based on the disclosure provided in D1 and a sentence which referred to D2 by stating: "Perfumes are generally described in U.S. Patent No. 7,186,680 at column 10, line 56, to column 25, line 22". In the opinion of t …
In T 1820/22 the board decided not to admit auxiliary requests 1 to 8 filed with the statement of grounds of appeal, nor auxiliary requests auxiliary requests 1a, 1b, 1c, 2a, 2b, 3a, or 4a filed with further submissions after the summons to oral proceedings. All these requests were filed for the fir …
In T 1823/23 the appellant (applicant) filed an appeal against the decision of the examining division to grant the patent in the version indicated in the communication under R. 71(3) EPC of 21 February 2023. The appellant requested that the patent be granted on the basis of the documents identified …
In T 1828/19 the board recalled that R. 99(1)(c) EPC requires that the notice of appeal contain a request defining the subject of the appeal. R. 99(2) EPC required that the appellant indicate in the statement of grounds of appeal the reasons for setting aside the decision impugned and the facts and …
In T 1841/23 the board had accelerated the appeal proceedings due to parallel infringement proceedings before the Unified Patent Court. The board summoned the parties to oral proceedings to be held on 11 December 2024. According to its preliminary opinion, the patent was most likely to be revoked on …
In T 1846/20 the appeal was lodged by the patent proprietor (appellant) against the decision of the examining division refusing the request for the re-issue of the B- specification of the patent and the request for re-establishment of rights. The application for the patent was filed on 16 June 2016 …
In T 1849/23 claim 1 as granted was directed to a trailer oscillation and stability control device comprising, among other things, an angular rate sensor positioned and configured to measure the rate of angular trailer deflection about a hitch pivot point and to generate corresponding angular traile …
In T 1865/22 the board determined that the objective technical problem was to provide an alternative stripping composition. Considering obviousness, the board found that arbitrarily varying the concentrations of components in a composition, including changing the concentration of one component in f …
In T 1874/23 the board refused the request for re-establishment of rights and, as a consequence, rejected the appeal as inadmissible. The appellant's request for oral proceedings was found to be obsolete. The board recalled R. 136(1) EPC and noted that it corresponded to the principle of "Eventualm …
In the decision under appeal in T 1882/23, the examining division had rejected the applicant's request for re-establishment of rights in respect of the time limit for paying the renewal fee for the fourth year and the additional fee, and deemed the patent application to be withdrawn. The examining d …
In T 1886/22 the interpretation of feature F in claim 1 of auxiliary request 5, in particular the term "extends through", was relevant to assess compliance with Art. 123(2) EPC. The board did not agree with the approach taken in T 1791/16 that all technically reasonable interpretations of an ambigu …
In T 1893/22, the proprietor-appellant had requested an enlargement of the board due to the case potentially setting a precedent regarding proper representation in proceedings established by the EPC. The board held that the case did not go beyond what might be handled by a board with an ordinary com …
In T 1906/19 the board raised different objections in its preliminary opinion and at oral proceedings to which the appellant (applicant) immediately reacted each time with the filing of a single new request that addressed the objections. The board explained that it understood the wording of Art. 13 …
See also abstract under Article 12(4) RPBA. In T 1913/21 claim 1 read: "Use of an inhibitor of cysteine degradation for reducing the formation of trisulfide bonds in proteins, wherein the inhibitor of cysteine degradation is selected from pyruvate, methyl pyruvate, ethyl pyruvate, glyceraldehyde, a …
In T 1924/20 the board noted that the respondent's (patent proprietor's) line of argumentation regarding E1's disclosure and inventive step concerning claim 8 hinged upon a claim construction that was based on the description of the opposed patent. The board held that such a line of argumentation wa …
See also abstracts under Article 15a(2) RPBA 2020. In T 1946/21 the appellant (opponent) and the intervener argued that the right to priority had not been validly transferred to the respondent (patent proprietor) because the written agreement had only been signed on the filing date of the subsequen …
In T 1959/20 the invention concerned the automatic deletion of messages in group chats, for example in the context of social networks. In particular, the goal was to implement an "ephemeral group chat", that is, a chat whose messages are automatically deleted when a certain condition is met, for exa …
In T 1968/18 appellant I (patent proprietor) filed amended description pages during the oral proceedings before the board. Appellant II (opponent) took the view that an amended description constituted an amendment to the patent proprietor's appeal case within the meaning of Art. 13(2) RPBA 2020. Th …
In case T 1977/22, the opposition division revoked the patent arguing that the definition of certain parameters in terms of an open-ended range rendered the invention insufficiently disclosed, as these parameters could not be reproduced over the whole scope of the open-ended side. The board address …
In T 1984/19 the board found that while an opposition division must have a certain freedom in admitting or disregarding late-filed evidence, the reasoning given in the contested decision for not admitting D16 into the opposition proceedings was insufficient in view of R. 111(2) EPC. From the decisio …
In T 1986/20 the board made reference to T 2035/11 and distinguished the claimed invention from a real-time navigation system. The claimed invention concerned a system for supporting an operator in the tasks of shipping or warehousing articles, specifically by offering guidance to the designated art …
In T 1994/20 the appeal lay against the decision of the opposition division to reject the opposition. It was an object of the invention to provide an improved polyolefin composition suitable for the production of a pressure pipe with improved pressure resistance as well as impact properties. D3 rela …
See also abstract under Article 56 EPC regarding the purported technical effect of improved photostability. In T 1994/22 the appeal lay from the opposition division's decision to reject the oppositions filed against the European patent. Claim 1 of the main request related to Form II of selexipag, …
In T 2004/21 the claimed invention related to a chewing gum which provided a hydration or "mouthwatering" sensation to a consumer. The appeal was against the decision of the opposition division finding that the European patent as amended according to auxiliary request 1 met the requirements of the E …
In T 2010/22, the opposed patent concerned a headphone. It aimed at providing a headphone that does not completely shield the wearer off from the outside acoustic environment (referred to by the appellant as an "open headphone"). Given that the appealed decision only concerned novelty in relation to …
In T 2011/21, during the oral proceedings which were held by videoconference, the "Sirona" child safety seat prior use was inspected remotely by the opposition division. The inspection was transmitted by videoconference to all parties with every party having been given the chance to direct the came …
In T 2012/20 the appellant's representative had instructed the assistant via email on 13 November 2020 to promptly file an appeal. It was also indicated in the email that filing the appeal well before the expiry of the time limit would allow any possible shortcomings to be addressed, if needed. The …
In T 2019/20 the board had to decide on the admittance of auxiliary request 1 filed by the respondent during oral proceedings before the board. This request consisted of independent claim 1 which was identical to independent claim 17 of the patent as granted (main request) and 10 dependent claims, w …
In T 2024/21 the appellant submitted that it had been deprived of its right to oral proceedings during the examination procedure. The board recalled that according to established case law the right to an oral hearing was an extremely important procedural right which the EPO should take all reasonab …
In T 2027/23 the board identified three major takeaways from G 1/24: First, the wording of the claims forms the "basis" for their interpretation and the description and the drawings should always be "consulted" or "referred to". However, G 1/24 is silent as to the very purpose of such "consultation" …
In T 2029/23 the patent concerned a method for preparing gelatin-based candy that did not require a drying step or the use of a single-use starch mould to extract moisture from the liquid composition. The board decided to set aside the decision under appeal, in which the opposition division had con …
In T 2037/22 (PBAT resin composition), the appellant (opponent) alleged that evidence D4 and D5 should not be taken into account, since it would be derivable from decision G 2/21 that a lack of sufficiency could not be remedied by post-published evidence. However, the board observed that the analys …
In T 2047/21 claim 1 of auxiliary request 1b defined a container by means of a disclaimer. It was disputed among the parties whether this was a "disclosed disclaimer" or an "undisclosed disclaimer". The board explained that G 1/16 provided definitions for the terms "undisclosed disclaimer" and "dis …
In T 2054/19 the board recalled that the right to be heard under Art. 113(1) EPC also included the right not to be surprised by a decision which had been taken against the expectation that the proceedings would be continued. In the case in hand, the applicant had filed a first amended set of claims …
In T 2086/21 the board found that, as stated by the respondents (patent proprietors), the effects of improved hygroscopicity, high thermodynamic stability and high polymorphic stability represented a beneficial combination of properties possessed by Form B of apalutamide compared to the physical for …
In T 2103/22 the board, in order to assess compliance with the requirements of Art. 123(2) EPC, had to first determine the subject-matter effectively defined by claim 1 of the main request. In particular, the board interpreted the meaning of the following terms as well as the meaning of their combin …
In T 2116/22 the interpretation of the terms "coating" and "coated" in claim 1 of the main request was relevant to assess novelty. The appellants-patent proprietors argued that these terms had to be interpreted taking into account the whole patent. The skilled person would have understood the coati …
In T 2124/21 the appellant (applicant) had filed with the statement of grounds of appeal a main request and a first auxiliary request that superseded the sole request subject of the appealed decision. In its communication under Art. 15(1) RPBA, the board informed the appellant of its preliminary int …
In T 2132/21 the patent claimed priority from a US application filed in the name of four inventors. In the filing of the PCT application leading to the patent, the four inventors were named as applicants for the US only and a corporation was named as applicant for all other states. The appellant (op …
In T 2171/21 the board explained that there existed a difference between the conceptual disclosure of a number of possible combinations and the individualised disclosure of specific combinations. While the former might be a more economical way of drafting a patent application, it did not necessarily …
In T 2192/22 the claims related to improved processes for purifying polypeptides of interest, by increasing the amount of a polypeptide of interest bound to a cation- exchange matrix relative to the amount of one or more impurities bound to the ion- exchange matrix. The patent proprietor was of the …
In T 2194/22 the main request was identical to auxiliary request 1 filed on 11 February 2022, which was admitted and found to be allowable by the opposition division, and was in substance identical to auxiliary request II "new" filed during oral proceedings before the board on 28 April 2021 and not …
In T 2197/16 the appellant (opponent) had appealed the opposition division's decision to maintain the patent. In the decision under appeal, the opposition division had also ordered the patent proprietor to pay the costs of the oral proceedings to the opponent under Art. 104(1) EPC. The respondent (p …
In T 2224/21 the appellant (opponent) argued that it had not been proven that the applicant of the contested patent was the same as the applicant of the first application. It pointed out that it had been impossible for it to access all the relevant information relating to the disputed transfer becau …
In T 2257/19 the invention concerned a security element having magnetic elements in which the magnetic difference of the regions (magnetic codes) could not be detected by normal instruments, but exclusively by means of dedicated sensors. The appellant held that feature (H) was not disclosed in the …
In T 2303/19 the parties were summoned to attend oral proceedings at the EPO premises. The appellant (patent proprietor) requested in its letter dated 3 November 2022 that the oral proceedings take place by videoconference (facilitating attendance of the appellant's in-house counsel and reducing the …
In T 2352/19 the respondent (patent proprietor) had filed auxiliary request 2 only after the board's summons to oral proceedings, in reaction to the board's communication under Art. 15(1) RPBA. In this communication the board had indicated its preliminary opinion that the subject-matter of the reque …
In T 2360/19 the patent was based on a European patent application which was a divisional application of an earlier European patent resulting from an international PCT application. This PCT application claimed priority from 12 US provisional applications (P1 to P12). The opposition division, applyin …
In T 2363/22 the patent at issue related to a dry pet food which comprised a core and a palatability-enhancing coating that contained edible phosphate salt and yeast extract. In both the application as filed and the patent, the reduction in palatability resulting from the decrease in the phosphate s …
In T 2381/19 the board dealt with the second appeal filed by the applicant against the refusal of the application by the examining division. In the first decision, the examining division had refused the application based on Art. 123(2) EPC, against which the applicant had appealed. The examining di …
In T 2387/22 claim 1 according to auxiliary requests 9 to 11 defined the use of a Vacuum Metallised Pigment (VMP) in a flexographic ink formulation for providing the following technical effects: "fewer print defects, higher hiding and stronger colour and allowing a lower volume anilox". The responde …
In T 2391/18 the appellant (opponent) had argued that the description had to be adapted to amended claim I of the main request, since there was an inconsistency between said claim and the description. In particular, paragraph [0017] of the description referred to a weighing device which provides for …
In T 2412/22 the invention related to continuous learning of a deep learning model for a specific autonomous vehicle and the appeal lay from the decision of the examining division to refuse the application for lack of inventive step over D1. In its communication the board indicated to the appellant …
In T 2432/19, after the board had summoned the parties to oral proceedings at the EPO premises, the appellant (patent proprietor) requested that the oral proceedings be held by videoconference but did not give any reasons for this request. The respondent (opponent) invoked no reasons against holding …
In T 2463/22 the opposition division had held that the prior uses had not been proven beyond reasonable doubt (up to the hilt), in particular with regard to whether the products of the prior uses had actually been delivered. The parties before the board focused on which standard of proof had to be a …
In T 2465/19 there was agreement that, as set out by the examining division in the decision at issue, D1 represented the closest state of the art and that the subject-matter of claim 1 of the main request differed from D1 by feature i): "wherein the control contact region is spaced apart from the cu …
In T 2482/22 the appellant (opponent) raised for the first time during the oral proceedings before the board an objection of lack of novelty over D1. The appellant's representative justified the late submission by arguing that he took over the case from a colleague, who had overlooked the novelty ob …
In T 2503/18 both the patent proprietors and the opponent had appealed the opposition division's decision to maintain the patent in amended form. After all the patent proprietors' requests had been discussed at the oral proceedings and the board had considered them not to be allowable, the patent p …
In T 2517/22, in support of their argument of lack of inventive step, appellant 2 (opponent) had submitted documents D2 (operating manual) and D2a, which was the affidavit of an employee of appellant 2, Mr R. Already in the notice of opposition and again in their reply, after the patentee had put i …
See also abstract under Article 84 EPC. In T 2565/19 the board identified the problem to be solved as the provision of a method which can be used to discriminate between a TRH receptor sub-type in human cortex from one in human pituitary. The question to be answered in assessing the obviousness of …
In T 2565/22 the patent concerned a system for replacing a deficient native heart valve. The proprietor submitted in the written procedure that for each feature of claim 1 a basis could be found in the priority application D34. In its communication the board expressed the preliminary view that only …
In T 2599/19 the board decided that the main and sole request was not taken into account under Art. 13(2) RPBA 2020, as it was unable to see any exceptional circumstances justifying filing the request in response to the board's summons to oral proceedings. Claim 1 of this new main request was an ex …
In T 2643/16 of 3 June 2024, the board had to decide whether the applicant was entitled to claim priority from previous applications D1 and D2 when filing the application on which the patent in suit was granted. This was a final decision following interlocutory decision T 2643/16 of 16 February 2023 …
In T 2651/22 the patent related to impedance matched microwave quantum circuit systems, in particular to a system comprising a parametric amplifier for amplifying a qubit readout. The interpretation of the feature "impedance matching circuit" in claim 1 was relevant to assess inventive step. The re …
In T 2689/19 the European patent application on which the patent was based was a divisional application of an earlier European patent resulting from an international PCT application. This PCT application claimed priority from six US provisional applications (P1, P2, P5, P11, P13 and P14). The opposi …
In T 2703/18 the board considered the scope of the review under R. 64 EPC and the restraint to be exercised in the context of this rule. It noted that according to a number of board of appeal decisions the scope of the examining division's review under R 64(2) EPC (previously R. 46(1) EPC 1973) is l …
In T 2716/19 it was common ground that the subject-matter of claim 1 of the main request differed from disclosures in D1, D5 and D15 only in that magnesium t-butyl oxide or magnesium isopropyl oxide was used in lieu of lithium t-butoxide. However, the views of the parties diverged on the technical e …
T 2719/19 (of 20 November 2023) was the referring case in G 2/22 (consolidated with G 1/22). The application from which the (divisional) application in suit derived had been filed as an international application under the PCT (the "PCT application"). It named (i) the three inventors ("Party A") as a …
In T 2726/17 the board applied the principles of the protection of legitimate expectations and of good faith (citing T 14/89 as an example) and considered a notice of appeal filed via the EPO web-form filing service as having been duly received. The board pointed out that according to Art. 2 of the …
In T 2852/19 the invention related to optimising the occupancy of an event. The aim was to avoid seats remaining empty if visitors could not reach the event location in time. The invention proposed to automatically determine whether visitors to an event were in a defined area at a certain distance f …
In the case underlying T 2866/18 the opponent had raised lack of novelty objections against claim 1 of the main request on the basis of documents D10 to D13 as well as an inventive step objection starting from D13. In the decision under appeal, the opposition division had considered claim 1 of the m …
In T 2907/18 the board overturned the opposition division's finding that feature P7 of claim 1 was to be understood as a product-by-process feature and therefore held that claim 1 of the patent lacked novelty. In the opinion of the respondent (patent proprietor), this constituted special reasons wit …
T 2907/19 was an appeal against the decision of the examining division to refuse the European patent application. The invention concerned a method of manufacturing a semiconductor device on a silicon carbide substate. The application was a divisional application of a parent European application for …
In T 2916/19 the appellant raised objections of lack of novelty and of lack of inventive step against claim 1 of the main request. The board noted that an objection had already been put forward during the opposition proceedings but that the opposition division had not deemed it necessary to deal wit …