T 0248/22

Board 3.5.05
Date of Decision 2023-11-15
Language of the Proceedings EN
Internal Distribution Code D
Proceeding Type Inter partes
Official Keywords amendment to case - requests - admitted (no) - overcomes an objection that is part of the decision under appeal or the appeal proceedings (no)
In T 248/22 the board found that the main request and auxiliary request 1 could not be allowed - after the proprietor had withdrawn its appeal - as they were broader than auxiliary request 2 (reformatio in peius), and that auxiliary requests 2 to 5 were not allowable in their substance. Since auxiliary requests 6 to 10 were amended requests filed for the first time with the grounds of appeal and had not been previously presented in the proceedings, their admission was at the discretion of the board as per Art. 12(4) RPBA.

The proprietor argued that these requests could not have been filed earlier as they were filed in response to an objection by the opponent pursuant to Art. 123(2) EPC which was presented for the first time during the oral proceedings before the opposition division.

The board recalled that, in exercising its discretion whether to admit an amendment to a party's case, it had to consider whether the amendment was suitable for addressing the objections raised (Art. 12(4) RPBA). However, the board noted that, in the case in hand, the proprietor had argued that the amendments remedied an objection which was not part of the decision under appeal or the appeal proceedings.

The objection had neither been admitted by the opposition division nor maintained on appeal by the opponent. The board held that any reason as to why an amendment overcame an unraised objection did not constitute valid reasons for admitting an amended request in view of Art. 12(4), third and fourth sentences, RPBA.

In the absence of a valid reason for admitting auxiliary requests 6 to 10, the board decided not to admit them into these proceedings. The decision under appeal was set aside and the patent was revoked.

025-02-24